Surprisingly, the Wall Street Journal has some very good articles on Style. They recently pondered the question, “If you lost your entire wardrobe, how would you go about replacing it?
Donna Karan Says: Seven Easy Pieces
“You don’t need a lot of pieces, just the right ones, so think versatility,” said Donna Karan. For starters, the fashion designer recommends a simple dress that can be worn by day and jazzed up for evening. A body-tailored jacket is a must—as part of a suit or as a light coat—as is a bare top that can be covered up or worn on its own at night. “I would also want a skirt that flatters your shape, slim pants that can be suited or worn casually, a cashmere sweater to throw over everything and an evening piece that’s sexy and illuminating,” she added. Voilà! There, in a nutshell, is Ms. Karan’s Seven Easy Pieces system of flexible dressing. “Each piece is a mini-wardrobe, designed to be worn multiple ways. I love seasonless fabrics such as crepe and jersey,” she said. From her spring collection, Ms. Karan favors an off-the-shoulder ivory zip jacket and one of her twisted jersey dresses.
Carolina Herrera Says: Perfect White Shirt
Carolina Herrera, lauded as much for her own style as for the clothes she designs, would immediately replace the item for which she’s most well-known: the white shirt. “For day or evening it’s a staple all women should have,” she said. “It’s an easy element for anyone to wear and most importantly, to wear it in her own way.” Ms. Herrera’s starter gear is comprised of classic separates but with a modern touch. “If you have a few pieces you can mix and match to create an interesting look for yourself, you can build on them,” she said.
Vera Wang Says: Leggings and a Cardigan
“Replacement would be focused on underpinnings,” said Vera Wang. “I would immediately buy leggings. They’re my middle name. T-shirts—Rick Owens or my own label—and sweaters are important for me. I like to layer so both would be thin silk and cashmere weaves or light viscose chiffon. I’m such a hoarder I couldn’t redo my entire closet unless it was a catastrophic circumstance. I’d be heartbroken if I lost my cardigan collection,” she added. Ms. Wang’s go-to piece for spring is her signature short-to-long skirt. “You can work it with a legging by day and a high heel by night.”
Nanette Lepore Says: Reinvent Yourself
Designer Nanette Lepore thinks having to replace everything is a unique opportunity for self reinvention. “Sometimes you build up in your mind what you had and loved, sort of like the boyfriend that got away,” she said. “The instinct is to recreate what you lost. First buy what you’re most obsessed with so you don’t think about the loss and then break the mold.” From her spring collection, Ms. Lepore would start with wide-leg, high-waisted 1940s-movie-star-style trousers in pale blue. “I would reinvent myself and become a glamour girl,” she said. Another top pick is a blazer and pleated skirt in hot tangerine, and a lace pastel dress with a neon slip underneath.
Rachel Roy Says: Stay Timeless
For Rachel Roy, a shift dress and classic trench coat are jump-start pieces. “Both make you feel strong and confident,” she said. “The trench can be worn as a dress and feminized with a statement necklace.” The designer’s advice for building a new wardrobe is to go for a poised, timeless look with an edge. “I love a fitted button-down shirt tucked into a red cropped pant and topped off with a pair of snakeskin shoes.” Choosing from her own collection, Ms. Roy recommends a romantic pantsuit in a neutral color, a silk pajama shirt and one of her black-and-white graphic floral dresses. “I think all of them embody effortless chic.”
Gigi Mortimer Says: Pack and Learn
Gigi Mortimer, co-founder of the clothing and accessories label Glamourpuss NYC, equates building a new wardrobe with packing for a trip: “Each time you pack, you re-evaluate your image and start fresh. You decide on the key pieces you need to feel comfortable, confident and chic.” Ms. Mortimer’s fundamental items include a white stretch cotton button-down shirt, a V-neck camel cashmere sweater and well-fitting jeans in navy and white. “I’d also buy a trench coat—the color isn’t as important as the cut. To this I’d add straight black cropped pants. For night, dressy black trousers and a white silk shirt with interesting detail. Starting over would be fun. Having been in the fashion business for so long I don’t get attached to anything. Every season you find something great.”
Amy Fine Collins Says: Develop Designer Relationships
Not so for Amy Fine Collins, whose closet is sacred territory and each garment has a historical narrative attached to it. “I don’t love shopping. I never wear a designer I don’t know. What I like is the dialogue between the designer and me,” said the fashion writer, who has earned a place in the International Best-Dressed List Hall of Fame. If forced to rebuild, Ms. Collins said she would create a fresher identity with a new designer who has an exciting future. For now, she’d make an SOS call to Carolina Herrera, Stacey Bendet of Alice & Olivia and her new favorite, Paola Quadretti. Her emergency kit would consist of two black dresses—one for evening and a workhorse day piece. “I’d buy a cardigan with special detail on it and a pencil skirt in a print like leopard or stretch tweed and two black scooped-neck cashmere sweaters—one long-sleeved and one tank. The palette would be black and white to get it all going quickly, and for spring, I’d choose a dress with horizontal stripes. Accessories are the hardest items to replace. I’ve never thrown out a belt in my life.”
Carolyne Roehm Says: Be True to Yourself
Carolyne Roehm, fashion-designer-turned-lifestyle-expert and author, was forced to replace her wardrobe in 1999 when she lost it all in a fire at her Connecticut home. “I followed the less-is-more approach and only bought things of enduring style and quality. That latter gave way to whims based upon the fashions of the moment—at the time it was difficult to find what the French call ‘le grande classique,’ so whenever I found them I would buy in three or four classic colors. I built a huge inventory of clothes. Today, I would make a realistic assessment of my lifestyle needs and ask myself what are the pieces that set me apart from the crowd in a positive way and what items reflect my personal style and not one currently promoted in fashion media. I would base a new wardrobe on exciting accessories and build classics around them.”
Lauren Santo Domingo Says: Be Provocative
Lauren Santo Domingo’s philosophy is the polar opposite of Ms. Roehm’s. “I wouldn’t stick with classics,” said the co-founder of Moda Operandi, the online boutique that allows customers to pre-order the latest runway collections. “I say invest in fashion because it’s an opportunity to revamp your wardrobe. I’m drawn to the more provocative pieces in a collection. The foundation would be a basic shift dress but a bit conceptual so that I wouldn’t get bored. Limited options frustrate me so I’d push the envelope. Givenchy, Balenciaga or Proenza Schouler would likely have something that fits the bill. I would immediately replace my jeans and buy several pairs of the same ones. From there I would buy staples from a one-stop shop like J.Crew or Brooks Brothers.”
What would I buy? For me, it’s not about what but where. When I shop I can be pathologically indecisive or weirdly impulsive, so the task would be some version of a Rorschach test. I’m at a point in my life where I would turn to a stylist or buyer whose taste I trust. I wouldn’t shop a department store—way too overwhelming—even though many of them have excellent personal shoppers; nor would I choose one specific designer’s freestanding shop. I’d rather select a boutique where the owner has a well-edited collection of clothes by a variety of designers, and has thoughtfully selected pieces that can all work well together. I like Diane Firsten in Palm Beach and Gail Rothwell in East Hampton.